When Bilbo Baggins left Hobbiton for the second time after his birthday party he left presents. One of the presents was a waste paper bin for his aunt who had written him reams of advice for decades. Advice in Tolkiens world is a dangerous thing not to be given or taken lightly. Frodo says “do not go to the elves for council for they will say yes and no”. At Rivendell (where elves still dwell) the aged Bilbo meets the adventurous Hobbits on their return from the War of the Ring. He gives some small gifts and good advice. He tells Merry and Pippin not to let their ‘heads get too big for their heads’. Not a Middle Earth story but in Farmer Giles of Ham the titular farmer is advised by the Parson to ‘trust his luck and bring some rope’. Sam could have appreciated that advice for one thing he wanted was some rope. Farmer Giles was also advised by his dog Garm to be ‘bold and quick’ when confronting the giant who was trampling his lands.
The worst advice I have ever heard is from Indiana Jones where the villain Donnovan tells Indiana to not trust anyone and then reveals himself to be untrustworthy. This is of course a great device in the film itself and a wonderful plot twist BUT it is so corrosive as advice. If you don’t trust anyone you are cut off from other people and begin to atrophy.
So from this I would take away be careful who you ask for advice but when you find someone down to earth and sensible remember to not let your heads get too big, be bold and quick when facing adversity or opportunity (those two look so very similar), trust to your luck and remember some rope.










